Man Arrested After Allegedly Threatening to Mutilate Kittens and Throwing Their Severed Tails at Woman

Green, OH – A 57-year-old man faces serious allegations of animal cruelty following a troubling incident reported Friday, April 11. Authorities say Bret Stalnaker was taken into custody after an alleged altercation with a female resident on East Turkeyfoot Lake Road, leading to shocking claims of cruelty towards newborn kittens.

The Summit County Sheriff’s Office arrived at the scene after receiving reports of a verbal dispute between Stalnaker and the female resident. Upon investigation, deputies discovered that Stalnaker had been living in a van on the property. The situation apparently escalated after a conflict arose earlier in the day, during which Stalnaker allegedly threatened the woman via text messages.

According to the sheriff’s office, Stalnaker reportedly threatened to cut off the tails of the kittens, born just over a week prior. The threats reportedly included intentions to harm not only the newborn kittens but also their mother, sending a chilling message to the woman who had sought refuge in a detached garage.

In a shocking turn of events, Stalnaker allegedly threw a container at the woman, which contained the severed tails of three kittens. This act reportedly occurred shortly after the threatening messages were sent, painting a distressing picture of cruelty and violence towards vulnerable animals.

Upon the deputies’ arrival, Stalnaker was ordered to exit his vehicle. In a concerning development, he allegedly threw an object as he exited, which was later found to be a loaded .45-caliber pistol. The weapon raised further alarms for the law enforcement officers on scene.

As a result of these allegations, Stalnaker has been charged with animal cruelty, classified as a fourth-degree felony. He has since been transported to Summit County Jail, where he awaits further proceedings that may include additional charges, depending on the outcome of the investigation.

The injured kittens were rushed to a local veterinarian, where they are reportedly receiving treatment for their injuries. The swift response demonstrates concerns not only for the wellbeing of the animals but also for the potential dangers posed by Stalnaker’s actions.

Animal cruelty cases evoke strong community responses, and this incident has already drawn attention from local animal advocates and organizations, illustrating the deep emotional impact such events have on residents. The investigation continues as authorities delve into the allegations surrounding Stalnaker’s conduct and its ramifications for both the kittens and the community.

Residents in Green now face the unsettling reality of such actions occurring within their neighborhood, prompting discussions about animal safety and vigilance within the community. As this story develops, more details are anticipated to surface, shedding light on the ongoing investigation and its implications for Stalnaker’s future.